The Short Answer
The difference is scope. An HMI lets an operator run the machine in front of them. SCADA sits above many machines, often across several sites, collecting data centrally so a control room can see and manage everything at once.
-
//
Scope HMI: one machine, cell or process. SCADA: a plant, a pipeline or a network of sites.
-
//
Data HMI: live values, with limited local logging. SCADA: a central historian for trends and reports.
-
//
Location HMI: at the machine. SCADA: servers and a control room, with HMI clients in the field.
-
//
Alarms HMI: local alarms. SCADA: plant-wide alarm management and escalation.
How They Work Together
Most modern systems use both. Machine-level HMIs handle local operation, while the same screens, or SCADA clients running on panel PCs, give operators access to plant-wide data. If the local HMI fails, the machine can usually still be run from SCADA, and the other way round.
Hardware for Each
HMIs run on panel PCs and touch monitors at the machine; SCADA runs on servers, with large industrial monitors in the control room. Our guide to choosing an industrial HMI covers the machine side.